ASSALAMU ALAIKUM WARAHMATULLAHI WABARAKATUH
MAHMOOD BIN IS’HAAQ KI BAYAN KARDAH HADEES PAR IBN HAJAR RH KI TAHSEEN PAR AITERAZ KA JAIZAH
MAHMOOD BIN IS’HAAQ IMAM BUKHARI RH KI KITAB JUZZ RAFUL YADAIN AUR JUZZ AL QIR’AT KE RAAWI HAIN IS RAAWI KI BAYAN KARDAH HADEES KO IBN HAJAR RH ne HASAN kaha hai dekhiye
[[ MAWAFIQATUL KHABAR UL KHABAR JILD 1 SAFA 417 ]]
SCAN
ASSALAMU ALAIKUM WARAHMATULLAHI WABARAKATUH
KYA JUZZ AL RAFUL YADAIN AUR JUZZ AL QIRAT IMAM BUKHARI RH KI KITAB NAHI HAI?
Baaz logo’n ko ye kehte hue suna gaya hai ki ye KITABE’N IMAM BUKHARI RH se SAABIT nahi hai
In logo’n ke is AITERAZ ki BUNIYAAD ye hai ki in dono KITAB ki SANAD me ek RAAWI “MAHMOOD BIN IS’HAAQ ALBUKHARI ALKHAZAA’E ALQAWAAS RAHIMAULLAH ( محمود بن اسحاق البخاري الخزاعي القواس) hain aur in par ye AITERAZ kiya jaata hai ki ye MAJHOOL hain aur isi bina par ye kaha jaata hai ki ye IMAM BUKHARI RH ki KITAAB nahi hai
IN SHA ALLAH AAJ IS POST ME IS RAAWI KE BAARE ME TAFSEELI GUFTUGU HOGE
Chunancha ab MAHMOOD BIN IS’HAAQ RAHIMAULLAH ki SAREEH aur GHAIR SAREEH TAUSEEQ ke HAWAALE PESH E KHIDMAT hain
HAAFIZ IMAM IBN HAJAR ASQALANI RH ne MAHMOOD BIN IS’HAAQ ki BAYAN KARDAH ek RIWAYAT ko “HASAN” QARAR diya hai
[[ MAWAFIQATUL KHABAR UL KHABAR JILD 1 SAFA 417 ]]
SCAN
Ahlehadith blog 